Science & Environment · Published October 5, 2026 at 8:53 PM CDT
Supreme Court Hears Case on Oil Companies' Climate Liability
What everyone agrees on
- The Supreme Court began its new term hearing arguments in a climate change case.
- The case involves Boulder, Colorado seeking damages from Exxon Mobil and Suncor Energy.
- The case concerns whether state and local governments can sue oil companies over climate change impacts.
- Oil companies are seeking to block the lawsuits from proceeding in state court.
Each fact above was reported by outlets on the left, center and right.
How each side framed it
Left-leaning outlets · 7
Left-leaning outlets emphasized the stakes for climate lawsuits broadly and described impacts of climate change, with some noting Chief Justice Roberts' potential role in the outcome.
Center-leaning outlets · 4
Center-leaning outlets focused on justices' questioning, noting some justices appeared skeptical of the oil companies' request and raised procedural questions about the case.
Right-leaning outlets · 3
Right-leaning outlets highlighted the oil companies' legal arguments, including claims that the lawsuits improperly use state law to regulate global conduct and exceed constitutional limits.
Still disputed
- Center-leaning outlets reported justices appeared skeptical of the oil companies' position; this characterization is not present in left or right coverage.
- Right-leaning outlets emphasized quotes from oil company lawyers describing the lawsuits as unconstitutional overreach, a framing not found in other sides' coverage.
Read the original reporting
- Left ABC News Killer beetles, tinderbox forests: Climate change costs center stage at Supreme Court Free to read
- Left CBS News Inside the cases the Supreme Court will take up this term Free to read
- Left NBC News Supreme Court hears arguments in climate change case seeking to hold companies liable Free to read
- Left NPR SCOTUS hears major climate change case. And, Brazil's presidential race goes to runoff Free to read
- Left The Guardian (US) US supreme court hears big oil’s bid to block climate damage lawsuits Free to read
- Left The New York Times Supreme Court Begins Term With Major Climate Case A few free articles a month
- Left Vox The Supreme Court is looking for a way to kill climate lawsuits Free to read
- Center AP News A new Supreme Court term begins with cases on climate change, immigration and gun rights Free to read
- Center PBS NewsHour Supreme Court hears case on holding energy companies liable for climate change Free to read
- Center The Christian Science Monitor Can states make Big Oil pay for climate change? Supreme Court weighs a precedent. A few free articles a month
- Center The Hill Justices appear unconvinced of oil companies’ bid to quash climate suits Free to read
- Right New York Post Supreme Court hears bid by Exxon, oil companies to avoid Colorado climate lawsuit Free to read
- Right The Washington Times Supreme Court wades into climate change dispute between energy companies and states Free to read
- Right Washington Free Beacon Supreme Court Hears Arguments in High-Stakes Colorado Climate Case Seeking To Hold Oil Companies Financially Liable for Global Warming: ‘Egregiously Exceeds Constitutional Limits’ Free to read
See a mistake?
A simple way to report a wrong or missing fact, with no sign-up, is coming soon. Every correction will be listed publicly.
This page was written by AI from each outlet's headline and short description, following our published rules. Always check the original reporting.